← ContentsCHEZ NOUS · 10 / 24

CHAPTER 10

Small Exhibitions

13 minute read

The gallery was called Third Space, and it occupied the ground floor of a converted rowhouse on R Street in Dupont Circle. The owner had hung Mila's paintings in the back room. Not the main room. The back room, which was smaller, which had a window that let in afternoon light from the alley, and which people reached only after they had passed through the main room, where the featured artist, a man who welded scrap metal into shapes resembling birds, occupied every wall and most of the floor.

Mila stood in the back room on opening night and watched the light from the alley window fall across her canvases at precisely the wrong angle.

She had four paintings in the show. Three Virginia landscapes and a still life of peonies from the garden. The landscapes were good. She knew they were good. The largest, a view of the Shenandoah Valley at the hour when the ridges dissolved into haze, captured something about America she had struggled to articulate: its vastness, its recession, the way the land seemed always to be pulling away from you.

Nobody was looking at them. They were looking at the birds.

A couple drifted into the back room. The woman was tall, silver-haired, wearing the kind of linen that costs what linen should not cost. Her companion trailed behind with a glass of red wine held at chest height, as if protecting it.

The woman stopped in front of the Shenandoah painting. She stood for a long time. Mila watched from the far corner, where she was pretending to examine the wall label on her own work, which she had already read fourteen times.

"Oh, this is lovely," the woman said.

Lovely.

The word landed on the painting and sat there. Mila felt it the way she felt a brush that slipped, the small, irreversible wrongness of a mark placed where it should not be.

Lovely was the word people used when they did not know what else to say. You said lovely about a sunset you glanced at from a car window, about a scarf someone was wearing, about the arrangement of appetizers on a plate. Lovely was the word that meant: I see this and I am not going to think about it. Lovely was the compliment that erased.

"Mm," the man said, which was less than lovely.

They moved on. The woman paused briefly at the peonies, tilted her head, and said, "Pretty." Then they were gone, back to the main room, back to the birds.

Mila stood alone with her paintings and listened to the party continue without her.


The review in the Washington City Paper was four sentences long. The metal bird sculptor received two paragraphs and a photograph. The review in the Falls Church News-Press was kinder: a full quarter-page, with a reproduction the newsprint made slightly green. "Fournier brings a painterly refinement to the Northern Virginia art scene." Mila read the phrase "painterly refinement" and understood that it meant: she paints well, in a way that does not surprise anyone.

She cut out both reviews and put them in a folder in the bottom drawer of her desk. Her studio was the second bedroom of the house in Falls Church. Twelve feet by ten. The east-facing window gave good light in the morning. By afternoon, the light shifted and she had to work from memory, which was fine, but it was not the same as working from the thing itself.

Stefan had offered to build shelves. He had drawn plans. The plans included precise measurements, material specifications, and a notation system for organizing her paint tubes by pigment family. She had kissed him and said she did not need shelves, she needed a bigger room, and he had looked at her with that expression he wore when a problem exceeded the available resources, a look that was part concern and part calculation.

"We could convert the garage," he said.

"The garage is full of your things."

"My things could go in the attic."

"The attic has no stairs."

"I could build stairs."

He would have built the stairs. She knew that. Stefan expressed love through construction: shelves, systems, solutions. He saw a problem and he reached for tools. It was the most generous thing about him, and sometimes the most frustrating, because there were problems that could not be built away, and her career was one of them.


She taught her first workshop in 2001, at the Arlington Arts Center, a converted storefront where the fluorescents buzzed and the linoleum was the color of exhaustion. Twelve students, mostly older than her, all of them holding brushes with the careful uncertainty of beginners.

She was good at teaching. This surprised her. She had expected impatience. Instead she found pleasure. She liked watching the moment when a student saw what the water did to the pigment, how it moved and bloomed and could not be entirely controlled.

"Don't chase the color," she told them. "Lay it down and let it move. The water knows where to go."

An older man, retired Air Force, looked at his paper and said, "Ma'am, the water appears to be going off the edge."

The workshops filled. She added a second session, then a third. The students were loyal. They brought her gifts: bottles of wine, gift cards, a ceramic mug shaped like a paint tube that she secretly loved and would keep for twenty years.

The teaching paid better than the painting, which was not a high bar. She sold a small landscape to a dentist's office in McLean. A floral study to a woman who wanted something to match her sofa. A commissioned portrait of someone's golden retriever, which she painted well and hated painting and which the owner adored because it captured, she said, the dog's "essential sweetness."

She did not tell Stefan about the dog.


The problem with teaching was not the teaching. The problem was time.

She painted in the mornings, from seven until she had to leave for a class or a meeting or the grocery store. But the mornings were shrinking. Emails about scheduling. Phone calls from students who wanted private lessons. Preparation: mixing demonstration palettes, cutting watercolor paper, writing out exercises. Each task was small. Together they formed a wall.

By 2003, she was painting three mornings a week. By 2004, two. The canvases she completed were smaller than they used to be. Not just in dimension. In ambition. She painted what would sell at the holiday art fair at the Falls Church Community Center, where she rented a table every December. Landscapes of the Shenandoah. Florals. A series of barns she drove out to Fauquier County to sketch, red and photogenic against rolling green. The barns sold. Everything sold, eventually, for prices that covered her materials and a modest surplus.

She was painting what the market wanted. She knew this. She stood at her easel and mixed colors she had mixed before for subjects she had painted before and felt the careful, incremental narrowing of her range, like a river channeled into a canal. The canal was useful. The canal went somewhere. But the river had been wider.


In the summer of 2004, the Northern Virginia Fine Arts Review ran a feature. "Local Artists to Watch." Mila was on page seven. A quarter-page photograph of her standing in front of the Shenandoah painting, and a write-up that called her "a fixture of the Northern Virginia art community" and "a painter of quiet, luminous landscapes that evoke the European plein air tradition."

The phrase "a fixture" stayed with her. A fixture was something bolted to a wall. A fixture was there when you walked in and still there when you walked out and you did not think about it in between.

She showed the article to Stefan. He read it with the attention he gave to everything, which was total, and when he looked up she could see that he had registered the same things she had.

"It's a good photo," he said.

"Stefan."

"The write-up is thin. But it's exposure."

"Exposure to what? The people who read the Northern Virginia Fine Arts Review already know who I am. They take my workshops. They buy my barns."

"What do you need?" he asked.

It was the right question. He did not say "What's wrong?" or "Don't worry" or "Give it time." He asked what she needed, because in his architecture of love, needs were specifications, and specifications could be addressed.

"I don't know," she said. This was true and also a lie. She knew what she needed. She needed time. She needed a room larger than twelve feet by ten. She needed someone to see the work, really see it, the way Stefan had seen it that first night at the Hiddingh Hall exhibition, when he had stood before her mountain studies and not moved.

"I could build you a website," he said.

She laughed. It came out sharper than she intended, a bark of surprised affection. "A website."

"A good one. With high-resolution images. A biography. A portfolio. People find artists online now."

"Stefan, I am not sure the internet is looking for a French woman who paints barns in Fauquier County."

"You don't only paint barns."

"Lately I mostly paint barns."

He looked at her. The look was quiet, steady, the look he had given her when she said she was not ready, in Cape Town, a lifetime ago. He saw her. He had always seen her. That was the blessing and the affliction: Stefan van den Berg saw what she was, even when what she was had contracted to fit a space too small for it.

He built the website anyway.

It was beautifully organized. Her paintings arranged chronologically, then by subject, then by medium, with a toggle he had coded himself. Each image color-corrected. The biography factual and warm. He showed it to her on a Saturday evening, the laptop open on the kitchen table between their dinner plates.

"It's wonderful," she said. And it was.

Nobody visited it. Stefan installed analytics, because of course he did, and he checked the numbers weekly with the restrained hopefulness of a farmer watching for rain. Fourteen visitors in the first month. Twenty-one in the second. Most of them, he admitted, were probably him.

"I check it from different browsers," he said. "To make sure the formatting holds."

"You are inflating my metrics."

"Marginally."

She kissed his forehead. The website glowed on the screen between them, her life's work arranged and catalogued and illuminated, a beautiful room that no one entered.


The Athenaeum show in Alexandria, October 2005, was the best thing that had happened to her in three years. Greek Revival, white columns, soaring ceilings. For the first time in years her work was hung where the lighting was correct and the walls were the right shade of white and the paintings could do what paintings were supposed to do, which was stop you.

She dressed for the opening. A black dress, the good earrings, the red silk scarf from Lyon. Stefan wore the blue jacket she liked. His hand on the small of her back, light and steady, a gesture so habitual it had become part of her body's architecture.

A man stood in front of her Great Falls canvas for a full two minutes. She watched his eyes move across the surface the way she watched students when they first began to see. He was seeing.

Then he moved on, and she heard him say to his companion, "That French painter, Fournier, she does these beautiful landscapes."

Beautiful landscapes. She filed it in the same place she had filed lovely, in the drawer where compliments went to be flattened into something that could not cut. A woman from a Fairfax art guild said her light was "reminiscent of the Barbizon school," which was both a compliment and a cage, because it placed her inside a tradition two hundred years old and safely dead.

On the drive home, Stefan was quiet. The Beltway was empty at this hour, the lanes wide and dark.

"Are you happy?" he asked.

The question arrived without warning. She turned from the window, where she had been watching the highway lights streak past, each one a small flare that existed for an instant and was gone.

"I am content," she said.

He glanced at her. In the dashboard light his face was all planes and shadows, the wire-rimmed glasses catching the glow of the instrument panel. He did not ask the follow-up question. He did not say, "Is that the same thing?" He drove, and she looked out the window, and the distinction between happy and content sat between them on the center console like a stone neither of them picked up.

Content meant: I have enough. The house is warm, the work is steady, the man beside me loves me.

Happy meant something else. Happy meant the mornings in Cape Town when she had painted for twelve hours and looked up and the mountain was there and the light was going and she had not eaten and she did not care because the painting was alive and so was she, so fully and recklessly alive that the distinction between herself and the work had dissolved.

She had not felt that in years. She painted well. She painted carefully. She had become, without deciding to, exactly what the silver-haired woman and the Georgetown gallerist and the Northern Virginia Fine Arts Review wanted her to be: a fixture. That French painter who does those beautiful landscapes.

She was thirty-two years old, and she was content, and content was a room with the curtains drawn.


That night, after Stefan had gone to bed, she walked to the end of the hallway, to the closet where they kept the things that had no other place: winter coats, the vacuum cleaner, a box of tax returns from 1999. On the top shelf, behind a duffel bag Stefan used for the gym, there was a portfolio case. Black leather, scuffed at the corners, the zipper stiff from years of disuse. She had packed it when they moved from the Arlington townhouse. She had packed it when they moved from Cape Town. She had carried it across an ocean, twice, without opening it.

Inside were the paintings she had made at seventeen, on her first visit to the Dordogne, when Aunt Mathilde had taken her to the farmhouse near Sarlat and the light had come through the walnut trees and hit the stone walls and she had painted it, all of it, with the furious, untrained certainty of someone seeing something for the first time.

She did not open the portfolio. She stood in the hallway in the dark, her fingers touching the scuffed leather. She could feel the weight of what was inside, not in grams but in years, in distance, in the gap between the girl who had painted that light and the woman who stood here now in a house in Falls Church, Virginia, content.

She left it where it was. She closed the closet door. She walked back down the hallway and into the bedroom, where Stefan was asleep with a book open on his chest, his glasses still on, the bedside lamp casting a warm circle of light that ended exactly at the edge of her side of the bed.

She removed his glasses, folded them, set them on the nightstand. Closed his book, keeping his place with the receipt he used as a bookmark. Turned off the lamp.

In the dark, she lay beside him and listened to his breathing, steady and even. She loved him. She loved this house. She loved the careful, constructed life they had built together in this country that was not hers.

But there was a portfolio in the closet, and inside it was a version of herself she had not looked at in fifteen years, and tonight, for the first time in a long time, she knew it was there. Not as a memory. As a question.

She closed her eyes. Tomorrow she would teach the Saturday watercolor class. She would mix the demonstration palette. She would stand in front of twelve people and say, "Don't chase the color. Let it move."

The portfolio would be in the closet. The question would keep.

Outside, the Virginia night was deep and still, the mountains invisible to the west. In the garden, the peonies Stefan had planted were dormant, their root systems alive beneath the frozen ground, waiting for the season that would bring them back, though no spreadsheet could tell them when.